New York is a legal outlier that leaves grieving families with far less compensation than their counterparts in almost every other state. The core reason is a wrongful death statute that dates back to 1847 — a law written when the United States had fewer than 30 states and the concept of emotional damages was not part of legal thinking. In 2026, that 179-year-old framework is once again at the center of a fierce legislative battle. The New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death reform bill has passed the state legislature four times with overwhelming margins, yet Gov. Hochul vetoed it for the fourth time on December 5, 2025. With reintroduction expected in the 2026 session already underway, families filing wrongful death claims in New York right now face dramatically different — and dramatically lower — potential recoveries than families in nearly every other state.
New York’s 179-Year-Old Wrongful Death Law: What Families Cannot Recover Today
New York’s wrongful death statute, EPTL §5-4.1, was enacted in 1847 and limits recovery exclusively to pecuniary — meaning purely economic — losses. Under this framework, a surviving family member cannot recover a single dollar for grief, sorrow, anguish, or the loss of a loved one’s companionship, society, or guidance. The law asks courts and juries to reduce a human life to a financial ledger: lost wages, lost financial support, and funeral expenses. That is the ceiling.
This pecuniary-loss-only framework creates a brutal and counterintuitive outcome: the less money a person earned during their lifetime, the less their death is worth in a New York courtroom. A retired grandparent, a child, a stay-at-home parent, or a low-income worker may generate minimal or zero lost-earnings damages, leaving their families with recoveries that do not begin to reflect the depth of their loss. New York is one of only approximately two states — along with Alabama — that bars families from recovering for emotional loss in wrongful death cases, making it starkly out of step with the national standard.
What the New York Grieving Families Act Would Add
Senate Bill S4423, known as the New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death reform measure, would fundamentally rewrite what New York families can recover. The bill would amend EPTL §5-4.3 to permit recovery of damages for grief and anguish whenever a tortfeasor is found liable. Beyond unlocking emotional damages, the Act makes several other sweeping changes.
Expanded Claimant Class
Under current law, the list of who can bring a wrongful death claim is narrow. The Grieving Families Act would expand eligible claimants to include spouses, domestic partners, children, foster children, stepchildren, step-grandchildren, parents, grandparents, step-parents, step-grandparents, siblings, and any person who stood in loco parentis to the deceased. This expansion recognizes the reality of modern American family structures, which bear little resemblance to households of the 1840s.
Extended Statute of Limitations and Retroactivity
The Act would extend the statute of limitations for wrongful death claims from two years to three years, giving families more time to investigate, retain counsel, and file. Critically, the bill also contains a retroactivity provision applying its new rules to cases that accrued on or after January 1, 2022. That means families who lost loved ones in 2022, 2023, 2024, or 2025 — and who have not yet settled or gone to trial — could potentially benefit from the expanded damages framework if the bill passes in the 2026 session.
No Cap on Grief and Anguish Damages
One of the most consequential features of the proposed Act is what it does not include: a damages cap. The determination of grief, anguish, and loss-of-companionship damages would be left entirely to the jury, with no statutory ceiling. This mirrors the approach taken by states like California, which allows recovery for loss of love, companionship, comfort, and care, and Texas, which permits loss of companionship, society, and mental anguish. Use a personal injury settlement calculator to understand how uncapped non-economic damages can shift total recovery figures by hundreds of thousands of dollars.
The Legislative Battle: Four Passes, Four Vetoes, One More Round in 2026
The political dynamic surrounding the New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death bill is unusual: the legislature has passed it four consecutive times with strong bipartisan support, yet the governor has blocked it each time. Gov. Hochul’s December 5, 2025 veto memo stated that the bill “continues to pose significant risks to consumers” and cited concerns about “higher costs to patients and consumers as well as other unintended consequences.” Critics of the veto argue that these concerns primarily reflect the interests of the insurance industry, hospitals, and healthcare providers — all of whom face substantially higher wrongful death exposure under uncapped non-economic damages.
With the 2026 legislative session already underway, the bill is expected to be reintroduced as a fifth version. The political arithmetic has not changed: the legislature remains firmly supportive, and the governor remains opposed. Whether 2026 produces a different outcome — through a new bill that addresses the governor’s stated concerns, a political shift, or a veto override attempt — is the central question for New York wrongful death families right now.
How the Numbers Change: Wrongful Death Damages Under Current Law vs. the Grieving Families Act
The financial gap between what New York currently allows and what the New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death reform would permit is enormous. To illustrate the stakes, the table below compares key damages categories, current law, and the proposed Act. For families dealing with fatal car accidents specifically, a car accident settlement calculator can help model how grief and companionship damages would factor into total recovery once the law changes.
| Damages Category | Current NY Law (EPTL §5-4.1) | Under Grieving Families Act (S4423) |
|---|---|---|
| Lost future earnings | ✅ Recoverable | ✅ Recoverable |
| Lost financial support | ✅ Recoverable | ✅ Recoverable |
| Funeral/burial expenses | ✅ Recoverable | ✅ Recoverable |
| Grief and anguish | ❌ Not recoverable | ✅ Recoverable (uncapped, jury decides) |
| Loss of companionship/society | ❌ Not recoverable | ✅ Recoverable (uncapped, jury decides) |
| Emotional devastation damages | ❌ Not recoverable | ✅ Recoverable (uncapped, jury decides) |
| Eligible claimants | Narrow (distributees) | Expanded (spouses, children, parents, grandparents, siblings, step-relatives, foster children, in loco parentis) |
| Statute of limitations | 2 years | 3 years |
| NY median wrongful death settlement (all case types) | ~$294,000 median | ~$973,000 mean | |
The median and mean settlement data above — approximately $294,000 and $973,000 respectively across all case types — reflects the current pecuniary-only framework. Industry analysts expect those figures to rise substantially if the Grieving Families Act passes, particularly in cases involving victims with low income, children, or retirees, where economic damages alone produce minimal recoveries. Fatal workplace accidents, for example, often involve victims whose families receive very little under the current pecuniary framework — a workplace injury calculator can help illustrate how adding non-economic damages would alter those outcomes.
Winners, Losers, and What This Means for Your Wrongful Death Calculator
The New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death reform produces clear winners and losers. Winners include: families of children, whose lost earnings are minimal or speculative; families of retirees, whose economic damages are often near zero; families of stay-at-home parents, whose contributions are hard to monetize; low-income families, who are systematically undervalued under a pure economic model; and extended family members — grandparents, siblings, stepchildren — who currently have no standing to bring claims at all.
Losers under the proposed Act are primarily liability insurers, hospitals, nursing homes, and product manufacturers facing wrongful death exposure in New York. Without a damages cap, juries in New York City and other urban venues could return grief and companionship verdicts that dwarf current awards. Gov. Hochul’s veto rationale implicitly sides with this group, arguing that expanded liability will be passed through to consumers in the form of higher insurance premiums and healthcare costs.
For purposes of a wrongful death calculator, the state-law variable matters enormously. The same set of facts — same victim, same defendant, same liability — produces wildly different damages outputs depending on whether you apply New York’s current law, the proposed Grieving Families Act rules, California law, or Texas law. A wrongful death calculator that does not account for state-specific non-economic damage rules will systematically undervalue New York claims that will be litigated under the new Act if it passes — and especially claims with retroactive applicability dating to January 1, 2022.
Frequently Asked Questions About the New York Grieving Families Act and Wrongful Death
What damages can New York wrongful death families recover under current law in 2026?
Under EPTL §5-4.1, New York wrongful death families are currently limited to pecuniary — economic — damages only. This means recoverable losses include the deceased’s lost future earnings, lost financial support to the family, and funeral and burial expenses. There is no recovery for grief, anguish, loss of companionship, or any other form of emotional loss under current New York law. This makes New York one of only approximately two states in the country, alongside Alabama, that bars non-economic damages in wrongful death cases.
What would the New York Grieving Families Act actually add to wrongful death damages?
The New York Grieving Families Act wrongful death bill (Senate Bill S4423) would amend EPTL §5-4.3 to allow families to recover damages for grief, anguish, and loss of companionship and society when a defendant is found liable. These damages would be uncapped — determined entirely by the jury — and would apply alongside existing economic damages. The Act also expands the pool of eligible claimants, extends the statute of limitations from two to three years, and applies retroactively to deaths that occurred on or after January 1, 2022.
Why has Gov. Hochul vetoed the Grieving Families Act four times?
Gov. Hochul’s most recent veto on December 5, 2025 cited concerns about “higher costs to patients and consumers” and stated that the bill “continues to pose significant risks to consumers.” The governor’s position reflects concerns raised by the insurance industry, hospitals, and healthcare providers, who argue that uncapped non-economic wrongful death damages will dramatically increase liability exposure and lead to higher premiums and healthcare costs passed on to New Yorkers. Supporters of the Act argue these concerns are overstated and prioritize corporate interests over grieving families.
Which types of wrongful death cases are most affected by New York’s current pecuniary-only rule?
The current pecuniary-only framework hits hardest in cases where the deceased had limited or no earned income. This includes children, who have no work history; retired individuals, whose earning years are behind them; stay-at-home parents, whose contributions are difficult to quantify economically; and low-income workers, whose projected future earnings are modest. In all of these cases, the purely economic calculation produces recoveries that are a fraction of what families in California, Texas, or most other states could recover for the same loss. A wrongful death calculator modeling these cases under current NY law versus the proposed Act shows dramatically different outputs.
If the Grieving Families Act passes in 2026, could my family’s case qualify under the retroactivity provision?
Potentially, yes. The proposed Act includes a retroactivity clause that would apply its new damages rules to wrongful death claims accruing on or after January 1, 2022. If your family lost a loved one on or after that date and your case has not yet settled or gone to final judgment, you may be able to pursue grief, anguish, and loss-of-companionship damages if the bill passes and is signed into law. However, the bill is not yet law — it must pass the legislature for a fifth time and survive the governor’s review. Given the extended statute of limitations provision, families should track the 2026 legislative session closely and consult a licensed attorney about how their specific case timeline may interact with the Act’s provisions.
This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice; consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for guidance specific to your case.
Related reading: Cardiology Protocol Failure Verdict: $50 Million Award For Negligent Treatment Decision Post-Catheterization
Related reading: Hospital-Acquired Infection & Sepsis Verdict Damages: How Healthcare Negligence Creates $23M+ Liability
Margaret Whitfield is a Wrongful Death and Survivor Rights Advisor with extensive knowledge of personal injury law and settlement values across the United States. With years of experience analyzing wrongful death claims only (high value) cases, Margaret helps injury victims understand their legal rights and the potential value of their claims. Margaret is not an attorney and the information provided is for educational purposes only.